3 of the Best Pizza Joints in Heath, OH

Feb 25, 2022

Modern pizza owes its origins to Naples, Italy, where it became a quick and easy way to use up leftovers. Today pizza can be found everywhere in the world, and in the US, it’s one of our most popular foods. Cheese, bread, and the toppings of your choice come together in an almost magical way to please anyone’s day. In Heath, OH, we’ve got some of the best pizza joints n the area.

Three pizzas on display in front of a brick oven.

Elliot’s

A family-owned pizza joint, Elliot’s offers a wide variety of foods, but the star of their menu is their fresh pizza. They’ve got six basic pizzas, including the ever-popular pepperoni, and their classic with pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, tomato, and topped with freshly-granted mozzarella cheese. Their specialty pizzas are what sets them apart, covering a wealth of flavors that delight both locals and visitors alike.

The eight specialties include our favorite, the cilantro chicken, with marinated grilled chicken, fresh cilantro, onions, olive oil, and loads of delicious mozzarella. Their Mr. Pickle is a firm choice with vegetarians, as it’s loaded with garlic, shredded mozzarella, sliced pickles, Parmesan cheese, olive oil, Italian dressing, and topped with extra mozzarella. Don’t miss Elliot’s at 16 W Main Street, Newark.

Don and Sue’s Pizza

Don and Sue’s has been making pizza in Newark, OH since 1972. They’ve recently moved to new, larger premises at 645 West Church Street, Newark. They make a light, crisp base covered with a perfect homemade pizza sauce. The sauce isn’t too sweet, sot doesn’t distract from the awesome topping flavors. You can choose pizza in 9″ through to 16″ depending on your appetite. They have nine house specialty pizzas, the option to build your pizza, and a calzone choice too.

A popular choice is an Italian stallion, made with pizza sauce, pepperoni, salami, ham, onions, tomatoes, bell peppers, lettuce, and Italian dressing. We also really like the carnivore, with bacon, ham, hamburger, sausage, and pepperoni covered in loads of mozzarella cheese. Service is friendly, and the relaxed atmosphere lets you focus on your reason for being here, namely eating good pizza.

The Clay’s Cafe & Catering

Clay’s has been an institution in Hebron since 1934 when it first opened as a small ice cream parlor. As it became more popular, the cafe branched out into other foods to satisfy the demand for good quality food in the area. They now make some of the finest pizza in the area. It’s become a big hit with locals, visitors, and tourists due to the high quality of their fresh ingredients and friendly, speed service.

Their dough is freshly made throughout the day, and all their ingredients are freshly prepared. We’re a big fan of their deluxe pizza, topped with pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, black olives, hot peppers, onions, and mushrooms.

With pizza this good, you’ll want more to take home for later. Come into Coughlin Toyota today and pick up that new car to make your travel easier.

Image via pexels.com.

Posted in Licking County, OH Community | No Comments »